According
to Gene, Finny is ‘the perfect kid.’ In his small boarding school, Finny is
considered the “top dog” and the most popular. Finny, “had been the best
athlete in the school” (Knowles 16), and was particularly charming. He could,
“get away with anything” (Knowles 25). During the substitute head master’s tea
party, Finny was caught wearing his tie informally, but he was able to use his
social skills to extricate himself from the punishable offense. A daring
teenager, Finny was not afraid to jump out an exceedingly tall tree into the
lake below. This potentially dangerous act did not deter Finny; instead, this
challenge motivated him even more. Finny was not one to worry about what other
students thought of him. While getting dressed for the head master’s party,
Finny decided to wear a pink shirt. This was an unusual color among the boys at
the Devon school. No one, however, though to tease him since he was well liked
in the group. As Gene stated, “No one else in the school could have [worn a
pink shirt] without some risk of having it torn from his back” (Knowles 25). With
a friend like this, it must be hard for Gene to live in his shadow. How can
Gene be a supportive friend without letting jealousy get the better of him?
I am not sure that Gene thinks Finny is the perfect kid. Gene does say that Finny does some pretty courageous, daring, and what can be considered as rude things. That does not make me believe that Gene thinks Finny is perfect. I think Gene just believes that Finny is lucky and gets away with a lot of things that other kids couldn't get away with."He seemed pleased or amused in some unknown corner of his mind. Phineas was going to get away with even this" (Knowles 28). In this quote Finny has just worn the Devon School tie as a belt, and Ms. Patch-Withers and Mr. Patch-Withers didn't get upset with him. In a situation like this it would seem disrespectful to do such a thing, and Gene can see this. Gene then understands how lucky Finny is, and how Finny can get of the hook with anything.
ReplyDeleteCarly Newell
I disagree with Carly a little bit in that although Gene might not think Finny is absolutely perfect, he thinks very highly of Finny, beyond the fact that he has good luck. Gene describes Finny as "unique" (Knowles 28) and an "extraordinary kind of person" (Knowles 28), which are both tremendous compliments. I believe that Gene, feeling inferior to Finny's constant good nature and charisma, wishes he was as 'perfect' as Finny. Gene even admits to himself that although Finny is his "best friend" (Knowles 28), he "couldn't help envying him that a little" (Knowles 25). Even though, as Gene mentions, it is normal to envy your friends occasionally, I hope that Gene doesn't let his jealousy get in the way of his friendship with Finny and cause him to become a bad friend.
ReplyDeleteI disagree with the comment above, I believe that envy, if it is stopped early can be mended, but envy is a powerful emotion and it can rip friendships apart. In the book, Gene could put up with Finny a little, but after seeing him be praised and getting away with everything, Gene felt, “a stab of disappointment” (Knowles 28). This is the first time in the book that we see Gene going against Finny, and this shows a change in Gene’s personality towards Finny. If this continues, then maybe Gene will get too envious and jealous and eventually let his emotions out in an action to bring Finny down.
ReplyDelete